What Researchers Did
French researchers ran two randomized trials in 385 adults with acute domestic carbon monoxide poisoning to compare different oxygen treatment plans, including sessions of hyperbaric oxygen (HBO).
What They Found
In two randomized trials of patients with carbon monoxide poisoning, HBO showed no evidence of benefit over normobaric oxygen (NBO) in patients with brief loss of consciousness, and two HBO sessions did worse than one in comatose patients. In trial A (179 patients with transient loss of consciousness), complete recovery at 1 month was 58% with 4 hours of NBO plus one HBO session and 61% with 6 hours of NBO alone (unadjusted odds ratio 0.90, 95% CI 0.47-1.71). In trial B (206 comatose patients), complete recovery at 1 month was 47% with two HBO sessions and 68% with one HBO session (unadjusted odds ratio 0.42, CI 0.23-0.79).
What This Means for Canadian Patients
For people who briefly lost consciousness from carbon monoxide, this study found no evidence that adding one HBO session beat normobaric oxygen alone. For people who were in a coma, two HBO sessions were linked to worse recovery than one session. The abstract does not say which HBO plan is best, so treatment decisions belong with the treating medical team.
Canadian Relevance
No direct Canadian connection identified.
Study Limitations
The abstract reports results from a single hospital in France and gives unadjusted odds ratios only, and trial B compared one HBO session with two, so it did not test HBO against normobaric oxygen alone in comatose patients.