What Researchers Did
The researchers tested whether oxygen that had been electrically charged (ionized) lowered carbon monoxide in blood better than regular medical oxygen, using blood samples in the lab and 15 smokers.
What They Found
In a lab and smoker study, negatively ionized oxygen removed the most carbon monoxide compared with medical oxygen and positively ionized oxygen, using a device called Oxygen Ion 3000. In the lab part, diluted blood with different carbon monoxide levels was bubbled with 5 liters per minute of medical oxygen, negatively ionized oxygen or positively ionized oxygen for 15 minutes, and then the carboxyhemoglobin (COHb, carbon monoxide bound to blood) was measured. In the smoker part, 15 smokers breathed either medical oxygen or negatively ionized oxygen, and carbon monoxide in their breath was compared before and after. The authors reported the highest carbon monoxide removal with negatively ionized oxygen in both parts. The abstract gives no numbers for the size of the difference.
What This Means for Canadian Patients
This study looked at oxygen breathed at normal air pressure, not hyperbaric oxygen therapy. The abstract notes that hyperbaric oxygen is recommended for carbon monoxide poisoning because medical oxygen at normal pressure is not very effective. It does not test ionized oxygen in people with carbon monoxide poisoning. Its only human findings come from smokers, so it does not show what would happen in a poisoning emergency.
Canadian Relevance
No direct Canadian connection identified.
Study Limitations
The human part included only 15 smokers who breathed oxygen for a short time, the abstract reports no statistics or amounts to show how large or reliable the difference was, and it did not test people with carbon monoxide poisoning.