What Researchers Did
French researchers gave carbon monoxide (CO) detectors to 300 general practitioners who made home visits, then tracked how often the alarms went off and what happened afterward.
What They Found
In this prospective study, GPs using CO detectors on home visits reported 65 scenes of CO poisoning involving 79 victims between November 2001 and November 2004, and the alarm went off about once per 17,527 visits. Only 12 doctors reported these scenes, and 23 physicians left out some alarms they should have declared. Ambient CO went above 200 ppm in 25% of cases, and 91% of victims needed hospital admission. Hyperbaric oxygen therapy was used in two cases. Of 272 GPs surveyed, 91% found the detector useful for safety, but 59% did not plan to buy one.
What This Means for Canadian Patients
The study looked at finding CO poisoning during home visits, not at how well HBOT works. The abstract only notes that hyperbaric oxygen was used in two cases and gives no results for it. In most cases the reason for the visit did not point to CO poisoning, so the detector picked up cases that doctors might not have suspected.
Canadian Relevance
No direct Canadian connection identified.
Study Limitations
The study had no comparison group, 23 physicians did not declare their alarms so some events may be missing, and the authors say the device cost limits wide use and that its large-scale use has to be questioned.