What Researchers Did
The researchers looked at what happened to 31 people in a row with severe carbon monoxide poisoning who were treated with a breathing machine and hyperbaric oxygen therapy, and compared their results with those from another study of ventilated patients who got normal-pressure oxygen.
What They Found
In this comparison of 31 consecutive severely poisoned patients treated with ventilation and hyperbaric oxygen against another study's patients given normobaric oxygen, hospital deaths were 16.1% in the hyperbaric group and 30% in the normobaric group. Severe short-term memory loss was reported in 3.8% of the hyperbaric patients, compared with a 20% rate of serious neurological deficit after normobaric oxygen. Poor outcome occurred in 19.4% of the hyperbaric group and 44.3% of the normobaric group (p less than 0.05). Cerebral oedema (brain swelling) still caused three of the five deaths despite hyperbaric therapy, occurring 24 to 48 hours after poisoning.
What This Means for Canadian Patients
For people with severe carbon monoxide poisoning who need a breathing machine, this report describes lower rates of death and poor outcome in the hyperbaric group than in a separate normobaric group. The two groups came from different studies, so the abstract does not show that hyperbaric oxygen caused the difference. Deaths and brain swelling still happened in the hyperbaric group, and the authors say that head pressure monitoring and a head CT scan before waking should be considered in any severely poisoned patient.
Canadian Relevance
No direct Canadian connection identified.
Study Limitations
The hyperbaric patients were compared with patients from a different study rather than with a group treated at the same time, and the abstract does not report that patients were randomly assigned, so the groups may have differed in ways that affected the results.