Identifying and acting on potentially... (2015 study) Skip to main content
Review The Medical journal of Australia 2015

Identifying and acting on potentially inappropriate care.

Duckett SJ, Breadon P, Romanes D, The Medical journal of Australia, 2015

Tier 2, Indexed

Automatically imported from PubMed based on relevance criteria.

Summary

What Researchers Did

The researchers looked at Australian hospital discharge data from one financial year (2010-11) to measure how often hospitals gave treatments that other literature had identified as inappropriate.

What They Found

In a secondary analysis of hospital discharge data from all Australian hospitals for 2010-11, five procedures not supported by clinical evidence happened more than 100 times a week on average, and the most frequent was hyperbaric oxygen therapy for a range of specific conditions, with 4659 admissions. The rate of these "do-not-do" procedures varied greatly between hospitals, even among comparator hospitals that provided the procedure and treated the relevant patient group. As one example from a different procedure, an average of 3.3% of knee osteoarthritis patients at comparator hospitals received arthroscopic lavage and debridement, but four hospitals had rates of over 20%.

What This Means for Canadian Patients

The abstract does not test whether HBOT works for any condition, and it does not name which conditions the 4659 admissions were for. It describes hospital practice in Australia, where HBOT for a range of specific conditions was counted among treatments the authors say are not supported by clinical evidence. Patients considering HBOT can ask their doctor which condition the treatment is meant for and what evidence supports it.

Canadian Relevance

No direct Canadian connection identified.

Study Limitations

This was a secondary analysis of administrative discharge data from a single year in Australia, and the abstract does not say which conditions were behind the HBOT admissions or whether any individual admission was actually inappropriate.

This plain-language summary was generated with AI assistance from the study's abstract; it has not been individually reviewed by a clinician. Always consult the source study and a qualified healthcare professional. See our editorial policy.

Was this summary helpful?

Study Details

Study Type Review
Category Systematic Reviews
Source Pubmed
PubMed ID 26268287
Year Published 2015
Journal The Medical journal of Australia
MeSH Terms Australia; Hospitals; Humans; Hyperbaric Oxygenation; Incidence; Patient Safety; Quality of Health Care; Retrospective Studies; Unnecessary Procedures

Cite This Study

Share

Find a Canadian Clinic

Browse verified hyperbaric facilities across Canada.

View Canadian Facilities

Disclaimer: This study summary is provided for informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute medical advice. The information presented reflects the findings of the original research authors and may not represent the views of Canada Hyperbarics. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before making treatment decisions.

Last updated: April 1, 2026 | Reviewed by: Canada Hyperbarics Editorial Team | Editorial process | Research sources | Counts & methodology